.png)
Ankle Sprains: To Brace or Not To Brace
- evddawix
- Mar 28
- 6 min read
Ankle sprains are among the most common injuries, especially for athletes and active individuals. Whether it’s a sudden twist during a game, a misstep on an uneven surface, or even just an awkward landing, an ankle sprain can sideline you for days or even weeks. One of the most frequently asked questions is whether or not to use a brace after an ankle sprain. While bracing can be beneficial, the decision depends on the severity of the injury and your specific situation. Let’s break down when bracing is helpful, when it’s not, and the best braces for sports and activities.
Understanding Ankle Sprains
Ankle sprains occur when the ligaments in the ankle are stretched or torn due to excessive force or movement. There are three primary degrees of ankle sprains, each of which requires a different approach to treatment and bracing:
Grade I (Mild Sprain)This is the least severe type of sprain. The ligaments are stretched, but there is minimal tearing. Swelling and pain are usually mild, and the ankle remains relatively stable. In many cases, Grade I sprains can be managed with rest, ice, compression, and elevation (the R.I.C.E. method) and typically do not require bracing.
Grade II (Moderate Sprain)A Grade II sprain involves partial tearing of the ligaments. The ankle may become swollen, bruised, and more painful, especially when moving. In this case, a brace may be beneficial to provide additional support during the healing process and to prevent future ankle sprains when playing sport or being active.
Grade III (Severe Sprain)A Grade III sprain is a complete tear of the ligament, resulting in significant instability. This type of injury often causes severe swelling, bruising, and difficulty bearing weight on the affected foot. Bracing is recommended for physical activity, and in some cases, surgery may be required to repair the ligaments.
When Bracing is Helpful
Bracing is most helpful in the following situations:
Chronic Ankle Instability: For individuals who have experienced multiple ankle sprains, bracing can help manage chronic ankle instability. This condition occurs when the ligaments and tissues around the ankle are weakened due to repeated injuries, leaving the joint vulnerable to future sprains. A brace provides additional support to prevent further damage and helps stabilize the ankle, reducing the risk of future sprains.
Returning to Sport with a High Risk of Reinjury: If you’ve suffered a moderate to severe sprain (Grade II or III) and are returning to sports or activities that involve rapid multi-directional movements, pivots, or jumps, bracing can be crucial for protecting the ankle from reinjury. Activities such as basketball, soccer, and running, where the ankle is frequently subjected to high-impact forces and lateral movements, pose a higher risk for re-spraining. Bracing gives you the confidence to return to these sports while minimizing the risk of further injury.
Personal Preference for Confidence in Activity: For some individuals, wearing a brace provides a sense of security and confidence when returning to activity. Even after an ankle has healed, the fear of reinjury can linger, especially in those who play competitive sports. In these cases, bracing can act as a mental and physical support system, giving you the reassurance you need to move freely and reduce hesitation. If a brace helps a someone feel more comfortable and confident, it can be a valuable tool in rehabilitation.
During Rehabilitation: In the early stages of recovery from a moderate or severe sprain, bracing can help reduce pain and control swelling. It also limits excessive movement that could delay healing. After the initial acute phase, as you start strengthening exercises and functional rehabilitation, a brace can continue to provide support while you gradually increase your activity level.
When Bracing Shouldn't Be Used
While bracing can be beneficial in certain situations, it's important to recognize that not every ankle sprain requires a brace. For mild sprains or injuries that present minimal risk of re-injury, bracing might actually hinder the healing process. Here’s when it’s better to skip the brace:
Mild Sprains with Little Risk of Re-injury: If you've sustained a mild ankle sprain (Grade I) with minimal swelling and pain, bracing is often not necessary. In these cases, the ligaments may be slightly stretched but not significantly damaged, and the ankle remains relatively stable. Bracing in this situation can restrict movement too much and prevent the ankle from adapting and strengthening in all ranges of motion. The goal for a mild sprain is to allow the ankle to move naturally, so the muscles and ligaments can gradually regain their strength.
Encouraging Natural Recovery and Strength: One of the key principles of rehabilitation after an ankle sprain is to challenge the muscles and ligaments in a controlled way. Bracing can provide too much support, preventing the body from learning to move correctly and reinforcing the proper activation of the stabilizing muscles. By allowing the muscles to work through functional movements and progressive load-bearing, you're stimulating them to regain their strength and flexibility. If you rely too heavily on a brace, the muscles and ligaments may not be appropriately challenged and strengthened. If a brace is recommended for sports, your physiotherapist may advise removing it during strengthening exercises to fully engage the muscles, then wearing it again during activity for protection.
Building Confidence in Safe Exercise: After a mild sprain, it’s important to build confidence in your ankle's ability to function correctly without external support. If a brace is used prematurely or unnecessarily, it can lead to a false sense of dependence on the device, which can actually reduce confidence in your own ability to exercise safely. Gradually removing the brace and allowing movement through a rehabilitation program that includes strength training and balance exercises helps build trust in your body’s healing process.
Promoting Compliance with Rehabilitation: Rehabilitation for an ankle sprain involves more than just allowing time for healing—it requires active participation in exercises and movements designed to strengthen the ankle and prevent future injury. If a brace is used unnecessarily, you may feel that you don’t need to engage fully in your rehab exercises, assuming the brace will provide all the support you need.
Best Braces for Sports and Activities
When it comes to selecting a brace for an ankle sprain, it’s essential to choose one that’s appropriate for your level of injury and the activities you plan to return to. Below are two of the top braces for ankle sprains that are recommended for sports and active individuals:
ASO Ankle Brace: The ASO (Ankle Stabilizing Orthosis) brace is a popular choice for after recovering from an ankle sprain. This brace is designed to provide support and stability to the ankle without being bulky or restrictive. It features a figure-eight strapping system that mimics the natural motion of the ankle, helping to prevent further injury. The ASO brace is often recommended for athletes because it offers protection while still allowing a reasonable range of motion, which is ideal for most sports.
Hinged Ankle Brace: Hinged ankle braces are ideal for more severe sprains (Grade II and III) or those recovering from ankle surgery. These braces feature rigid hinges on both sides of the ankle to limit excessive motion while still permitting some flexion and extension. The hinged design allows for better control and stabilization of the joint, making them an excellent option for those returning to sports or activities with a higher risk of re-injury. Hinged braces are especially effective for sports like basketball, soccer, and football, where lateral movement and pivoting are common.
Final Thoughts
Whether or not to brace an ankle after a sprain depends largely on the severity of the injury and your activity level. For mild sprains (Grade I), a brace may not be necessary, and rest along with physical therapy may be all you need. However, for more severe sprains (Grade III), a brace is often recommended to provide extra support and protection for return to sport. Bracing can also be beneficial in cases of chronic instability, when returning to high-risk sports, or when it provides a sense of confidence.
Choosing the right brace, such as an ASO or hinged brace, can make a significant difference in your ability to return to your active lifestyle safely. As always, it’s important to consult with your physiotherapist to assess your injury and determine the best course of action. They can help you choose the most suitable brace and guide you through a rehabilitation program to get you back to your regular activities as quickly and safely as possible.
Comments